The
Challenge of Child Rights and Health on a Dying
Planet
(Let us not talk
falsely now, the hour is getting late.
The Watchtower. Bob Dylan)
..........................................................................................................................
Lesley Pocock
(1)
Dr Manzoor Butt (2)
Dr Thamer Al Hilfy
(3)
- Corresponding author
Publisher and Managing Director
medi+WORLD International
World CME
Vice President
Global Medical Strategies
Publisher
Middle East Journal of Family Medicine
Middle East Journal of Age and Ageing
Middle East Journal of Business
Middle East Journal of Nursing
International Journal of Economic Humanism
and Sustainability
New Paradigm Journal
Steering Committee
Global Citizens for Peace
Global Ministries for Peace
Executive Committee
Child-Watch
Director
World Recruiting Services
572 Burwood Road,
Hawthorn 3122
AUSTRALIA
Phone: +613 9819 1224
Fax: +613 9819 3269
Email: lesleypocock@mediworld.com.au
-
Maqbool Clinic, Research
& Training Centre,
Dhoke Kala Khan, Shamsabad, Rawalpindi.
Postcode: 46300
Landline: +92-51-4423929
Cell Phones:+92-333-5101196; +92-300-9707549
-
Head of community
and family medicine department
Assistant Professor, Alkindy College Of
Medicine, Baghdad, /Iraq
Mobile. +9647901734108
E-mail: thamer_sindibaad@yahoo.com,
thamer_center2005@yahoo.com
..........................................................................................................................
| ABSTRACT
Our
children are our future. Many times have we heard
this said but have we thought about the reality
of the statement and the kind of humanity and
state of condition our global tribe of children
will inherit? If we have not got it right up to
this point, in the collective history of our global
human population, can we really expect them not
to do an even worse job, when inheriting a greatly
depleted, and more hostile and overpopulated world.
Our
culture of destruction and violence has not worked
and has nearly destroyed the very earth we inhabit,
and the lot of every child on this very day, is
a 50/50 chance of being severely abused and deprived
during their childhood. And when they grow up
and realise their constant hunger was not due
to a global famine; the shame and the indignity
they bore was not due to their own innate unworthiness;
and that their childhood was not lost to some
great rite or initiation of humanity, or to some
great political or religious or national cause,
but lost to greed, pettiness, brutalism and ignorance,
they will view us just as we unfortunately are.
The
answer to the many problems facing children are
extremely complex, but yet, we would argue, also
relatively simple, as a caring, compassionate,
equitable and enlightened world could easily turn
the situation around, The human political legitimacy
principle proposed by the philosopher Lyndon Storey
tells us that "political legitimacy is advanced
by developing policies that are consistent with
all of humanity having an equal opportunity to
benefit". Surely all of humanity includes
children and the time is ripe to do something
now as philosophers such as Storey continue to
draw attention to the need for a global policy
framework. The need for conscious evolution as
a united planetary people, from this point onwards,
is becoming increasingly evident and is surely
worth considering.1
The
Special Rapporteur of the UN in his paper Child
Rights 1995 has put it far more succinctly: "There
is no way to thoroughly enumerate the various
ways in which children around the world are economically
exploited and physically mistreated. But the numbers
are great -- and the suffering widespread. Behind
the hideous imagery -- of children beaten or sexually
abused by parents; ravaged beyond their years
by hard living and drug abuse on the streets;
maimed by landmines or turned into killers by
war; stricken with AIDS -- are the all-too-common
struggles against disease, hardship, and family
or social traditions that compromise children's
humanity or subject them to physical and emotional
suffering."
Whether
exploited as child labourers or prostitutes, drafted
as young teenagers into armed forces, forced as
young girls into a lonely, abusive life as domestic
workers, deprived of an education to work on the
family farm, or denied adequate nutrition and
health care, children need help and protection
from an adult world that perpetrates most of the
abuse." 2
Whoever
has been running the world all these years, has
obviously not been doing it very well, and humanity
has been downtrodden and exploited in the main,
while abuse, disrespect, intolerance, commodity
and hype has been made the norm, if not the holy
grail. Then there is the dogma of many forms;
much of it the same primitive dogma that has contributed
to the appalling state we are in, and that has
actively worked against enlightenment and advancement
of all humanity, for millennia.
So
it is time for decent people to speak and act
with courage; there is little left to lose and
much to gain. We are living, conscious pieces
of the universe, evolved to the stage where we
are the universe contemplating the universe, yet
alone out of all the species on this beautiful
planet, we prey on and exploit our own children,
and pollute, poison and destroy our own habitat
and food sources - all for the most senseless
and worthless earthly ambitions: money and power.
But
this paper is not to add further weight of condemnation;
the hour is getting late and we need to take on
new values, like protect, inspire, respect, empathise,
dignify, sanctify, - moral obligation, adult responsibility,
- and basic rights and protection for the innocent
and powerless of the planet.
And
it is possibly the family doctor and their ilk,
who have the greatest opportunity and most privileged
position to do this. And many, many family doctors
do. They offer a beacon of rationalism, and a
centre of solace, in a mad world, and family medicine
encompasses the social, physical, mental and psychological
health of a child, and their need for basic amenities,
access to nutrition and clean water, a safe living
environment and safety from ignorance and brutalism.
If
we could just open our eyes and minds and assist
all who want to change our prehistoric predilections
for chaos, and bring up one generation unharmed,
that is, break the cycle, then there may be a
future for all. But the good people out there
need to be assisted and encouraged and this paper's
aim is to cut through the dross and distractions
of life and shed light on the true state of (in)humanity,
and particularly its most vulnerable and aggrieved
section, our own children. We therefore also,
in this paper, concentrate on pragmatic solutions
and set out to provide honest information on the
real state of humankind, and its children, on
October 22, 2007.
|
On planet earth 2007
we witness the great debasement of all. The
hour is getting late and perhaps it is not the
time to be destroying the last natural place,
or cutting down the last stand of trees, or
exploiting, commoditising and abusing each other
and our own young, but time to take a stand
and to take on new values like protect, inspire,
respect, dignity, sanctity, moral obligation,
adult responsibility, and unquestionable rights
for the innocent and powerless.
While the many problems
outlined above by the Special Rapporteur of
the United Nations, are complex, oppressing
and widespread it is also not that hard to fix
things - it just takes people to do the 'right
thing' every time they are faced with a choice
and to think about the wider, global ramifications
of what they do.
"But the more direct
injustices are perpetrated largely by adults,
and manifested in the large numbers of children
exploited as labourers and prostitutes or maimed
by war - and these require further public exposure
and protective laws that are actually enforced.2
"
In the last decade, an
estimated two million children have been killed
in armed conflict, many of them by some of the
100 million landmines thought to be concealed
in 62 countries. A total of perhaps four to
five million more have been disabled as a result
of their experience in war, and more than 12
million have been made homeless. 3
Changing the attitudes
of adults unfortunately will take quite a few
more millennia of continuing enlightenment or
perhaps the short, sharp, shock, which we are
most likely in for.
Fortunately there is
a wide range of organisations and institutions
committed to peace, equality and human development
but these do not necessarily extend to the realm
of family or national politics, to enshrine
basic rights. Also all humans do not have the
capacity to comprehend the longterm results
of their actions of their practices, and cultures
so rights need to be enshrined in law and disseminated
into communities via public education and practices.
Those with the intellectual
capacity to look at issues of problem solving
on a global scale, that is an academic approach,
need to - this can fall to family doctors, teachers
and on the macro scale academics looking at
all the issues that cause intra-human conflict.
Laws need to enforce
what is issued via public education as we have
managed, for example, to identify murder, globally,
as an antisocial act, and plants and animals
seem to have worked out the need to protect
their offspring,- why not the same for a human
child? The progenitors of the seed usually do
their utmost to ensure the optimum survival
of their offspring, but unfortunately child
abuse and neglect while proliferated by poverty
and inequity, occurs almost equally where this
is not a factor, leaving us with almost a unique
situation of endemic acts of violence against
our own young.
Coupled with human society's
primeval urge to prey on human society and exploit
and conquer, and no doubt our unrecorded history
(our REAL history) has been just as littered
with such abuse; so we have to look at the fundamental
basis of our society, those who perpetuate the
atrocities, which are often part of the basic
structure of many societies.
The rights of women and
status of women are linked very closely to the
status of children. An empowered mother would
fight to save her children from the many forms
of abuse, and a society that supports a mother's
rights, also supports children's rights. Educating
and empowering women and girls can only improve
the situation on so many fronts.
So we need to respond
on a personal, familial, community, national
and global level to combat those who have a
vested interest in the disempowerment of women
and children, those who would prosper from such
and those who refuse to see. Human thought and
action, on a personal scale is the essence of
the process.
An academic focus on
the very nature of the problem is one we have
sought to develop through Child Watch where
we encourage articles such as this, looking
at the global issues working against children
and their rights and empowerment, as a necessary
step to identifying and solving the problems.
Coupled with this is the need to rescue those
children who are living their lives in abject
misery.
Creative responses
While the problems for
the children of planet earth are immediate and
every day and if we are to break the pattern
that they go on to abuse and degrade their own
children, having 'learned the ways of the world'
then frankly we need to think and act creatively
Such responses need to
look at a broad range of issues: dignity, rights
to a safe and secure environment, adequate nourishment,
rights to education, a future, a habitable planet.
At least if society is
educated then we have a yardstick to respond
by. Educating society that children are people
too, - provides a moral and practical basis
to the protection of children. Treating children
with dignity, shows children and other adults
the same.
And educating children
about their own rights provides them with some
measure of protection and dignity, at least
to gauge their own lives against.
While with Child-Watch
we provide small missions like ridding blind
institutionalised girls of lice and scabies
in impoverished nations, approaches such as
"Scholarships for Life' have a more longterm
affect. 4The main Child-Watch mission therefore
is to 'buy' children out of slavery and provide
them with an education. Slavery is not necessarily
a sign of parental or familial neglect it may
be a necessary means of survival for far too
many children and their families, with the responsibility
therefore falling to those who are benefiting
from the child labour or those who are necessitating
it through unfair national or cultural denial
of basic rights.
In many poor countries,
children work to supplement meagre family income
or otherwise to help the family business. Although
they may not always work under the most desirable
conditions, most are not being intentionally
exploited by their families. The real issue
in such cases is not whether the children work
or not, but whether the conditions under which
they work are just, and whether they are being
denied other basic rights because of their work
-- such as the right to education, to freedom
from abuse, and to proper health care.
As for child labour,
while experts agree that there are few accurate
statistics available, the best estimates from
the ILO are that there are nearly 80 million
children under 15 working as labourers. It is
also estimated that the number of children under
18 involved in prostitution exceeds two million,
one million of whom are in Asia and 300,000
in the United States. 2
One creative response to this kind of complex
dilemma has come from Bangladesh. In reaction
to United States Congressional legislation mandating
a boycott of companies in the garment industry
that use child labour, companies in the garment
industry in Bangladesh began ousting children
from their jobs -- as many as 50,000 in a four-month
period. The result was that many of the children
were worse off than they had been when they
were working, having taken other, less desirable
jobs or living in the street -- but not going
to school. 3
In July 1995, after negotiations
with non-governmental organizations (NGOs),
as well as UNICEF and the International Labour
Organization (ILO), the Bangladesh Garment Manufacturers
and Exporters Association (BGMEA) signed a Memorandum
of Understanding stipulating that BGMEA would
ask "that no under-aged worker will be
terminated until the appropriate school programmes
for the workers can be put in place".3
"Poverty cannot
be accepted as a pretext and justification for
the exploitation of children," wrote Vitit
Muntarbhorn, until 1995 the Special Rapporteur
on the sale of children, child prostitution
and child pornography. "It does not explain
the huge global demand with, in many instances,
customers from rich countries circumventing
their national laws to exploit children in other
countries. 'Sex tourism' has spread its illicit
wings wide, and paedophiles search for their
victims in all parts of the globe. The problem
is compounded by the criminal networks which
benefit from the trade in children, and by collusion
and corruption in many national settings".
2
Iraq represents the depths
to which we have sunk as a global community
and is a constant source of shame, and deserves
a focus of its own.
Despite the country's
rich resources, Iraq's human development indicators
are now among the lowest in the Region. In 1989,
health care in Iraq reached approximately 97%
of the urban and 79% of the rural population.
Subsequently, these gains were halted and during
the 1990s there was a rapid increase in infant
mortality rates and deterioration in other health
indicators. Health outcomes are now among the
worst in the Region, with high maternal and
child mortality. At present the infant mortality
rate is 108 and the under-five mortality rate
130.5 per 1000 live births. The country is suffering
from a double burden of disease. There are major
infections, such as diarrhoeal diseases, acute
respiratory infections, malaria, tuberculosis
and leishmaniasis. 5
Educational reform
is one of the high priorities in the re-building
of Iraq. Enrolment and attendance rates have
diminished progressively, including a rate of
only 50% of girls attending in rural areas.
Family poverty is a major cause of drop-out.
| Table 1.
Undernutrition among children under-5 years |
| Year |
1991 |
1995 |
2000 |
2002 |
Arab States average |
Acute malnutrition
|
3.0 |
11.0 |
7.8 |
4.0 |
9% |
| Underweight |
9.0 |
23.4 |
19.5 |
9.4 |
20% |
| Chronic malnutrition |
18.7 |
32.0 |
30.0 |
20.1 |
28% |
These figures, derived
from several surveys, confirmed the serious
nutritional status of young children in Iraq.
About one in every five children was underweight
(low weight for age) in 2000, and almost one
third of children under 5 were chronically malnourished
(low height for age). Malnutrition declined
in 2002 and Iraq was approaching the levels
at the beginning of the sanctions in 1991. The
recent Iraq multiple indicator rapid assessment
survey (IMIRA) conducted in 2004 however does
not confirm the improvements. It shows that
malnutrition (weight for age) affects up to
13% of children and malnutrition (height for
age--stunting) affects 25%. Also, the UN Millennium
Indicators Database gives a rate for moderate
and severe child malnutrition in Iraq of 15.9%.
Iraq is one of only three Arab countries (with
Yemen and Comoros) in which incidence of low
birth weight exceeds 10%. Although more than
40% of adult males are overweight, chronic malnutrition
is common, as is anaemia in children, adolescents
and pregnant women. 5
The orphans of Iraq also
deserve a special mention, not only as one section
of society in greatest need, not just of food
and shelter, but love and kindness, and especially
as they are an integral part of the future of
Iraq and its people, - and what an opportunity
for us to get it right.
And we all like a happy
ending, which is why we focus our final chapter
on our colleague, and a family doctor, Dr Manzoor
Butt who works in impoverished areas of Pakistan,
and treats the poorer members of the community
and who has developed many strategies aimed
at the multiplicity of factors that can lead
to poor health and impoverished lives, particularly
of women and children of the region.
Dr Butt is an example
of an ordinary person (indeed a hero in our
midst) who makes the right decision every time
he is faced with a dilemma or problem. This
can extend to training of Female birth attendants
and women's health workers, to deal with obstetrics
and gynaecological cases for women whose religion
or culture prevents them from being treated
by a male doctor, taking proactive and practical
steps to counter malnutrition in his patient
population, providing modern medical care where
'traditions and cultural practice' may be harmful
to human health, providing access to making
an income by purchasing, for example a sewing
machine for impoverished female family heads,
to allow them to work for a living when no other
means was available; and by recognising that
blind institutionalised girls and other insitutionalised
children plagued by lice and scabies, deserve
dignity and relief , and then taking the steps
to provide such. Mostly our colleague stands
up for what is right, every time , and often
at great personal cost.
And while one person
cannot do it all, one good person can make a
huge difference. So on this day, in the history
of humankind, we encounter our final opportunity
to address the full scope of our humanity, before
our current choices put an end to the age of
man and an end to our place in the unfolding
of the universe.
- Storey,
L Humanity or Sovereignty (page9)
-
United Nations Department of Public Information
* DPI/1765/HR--December 1995
-
UNICEF website
- www.Child-Watch.org
- Country Cooperation
Strategy for WHO and Iraq 2005-2010
|