Marriage
Migration Associated with Distance in Bangladesh:
An Application of Polynomial Model
.........................................................................................................................
Md. Rafiqul Islam, Associate Professor
Correspondence to:
Dept. of Population Science and Human Resource
Development, Rajshahi University, Bangladesh.
E-mail: rafique_pops@yahoo.com
|
ABSTRACT
In
this study an effort has been made to
fit mathematical model to marriage migration
associated with distance of Comilla district
in Bangladesh. For this, data have been
taken from Yadava, Soni and Sabina (2002)
but the data is also available in Hosain
(2000). It is to be noted that Hossain
(2000) applied pareto exponential model
(Morril and Pitts, 1967). Yadava, Soni
and Sabina (2002) also applied exponenial
distribution to the same data and they
showed that exponential distribution provided
good approximation. In this study an attempt
has been given attention to show that
the polynomial model is also applicable
to the same data set. It is found that
marriage migration associated with distance
follows polynomial model. To verify the
stability of the model, cross validity
prediction power is employed to the model.
Keywords
and Phrases: Marriage migration Mathematical
modeling Polynomial Variance explained
(R2) Cross validity prediction
power (CVPP) F-test.
|
It is to be mentioned here
that mathematical modeling in Population Studies
especially in Demography (Fertility, Mortality,
Migration) in Bangladesh have been worked very
limited scale. In the era of globalization,
mathematical models are very realistic and sophisticated
mechanisms to express data in Mathematics. Mathematical
models are of great useful to demographers in
realizing the process in differentiating among
various variables to find out the functional
relationships and their dynamic behaviors among
various demographic phenomena. Finally, model
is important for prediction purposes Mathematical
models in demography are mainly two groups:
stochastic and deterministic.
Deterministic model has only
been discussed in the present study. Deterministic
models are used to describe the functional relationship
between variables that take definite values.
Traditionally, one can draw graphs of the demographic
parameters but very few of us know in the context
of Bangladesh which models are more appropriate
for the parameters.
Islam and Ali (2004) found
that age specific fertility rates (ASFRs) follows
slightly modified biquadratic polynomial model
where as forward and backward cumulative ASFRs
follow quadratic and cubic polynomial model,
respectively in the rural community of Bangladesh.
To observe the distribution or pattern of marriage
migration associated with distance in Bangladesh,
India and other countries of the world a number
of models have been fitted to the data set (Libbee
and Sopher, 1975; Morril and Pitts, 1967; Perry,
1969a and 1969b; Samuel, 1994; Sharma, 1984;
Yadava et. al. 1988). Hossain gave an atention
to build up the model of Sharma (1984) and Yadava
et. al (1988).
But these models did not
supply good fit and then Hossain used the Pareto-Exponential
model proposed by Morril and Pitts (1967) to
present the marriage migration related to distance
for his data of Bangladesh. Although Pareto-Exponential
model supplied better approximation than the
models of Sharma (1984) and Yadava et. al. (1988)
but not significantly fit to the utilised data
set. It is to be noted that proposed models
of Sharma (1984) and Yadava et. al (1988) are
suitable for Hinda community in India. For this,
Yadava et. al. (2002) tried to show that exponential
distribution provides a better fit to the distribution
of marriage migration associated with distance
than pareto-Exponential function as applied
by Hossain (2000). Also Yadava et. al (2002)
compared with pareto-exponential functin applied
by Yadava et. al (1998).
In this study an effort has
been given attention to build mathematical model
to total marriage migration associated with
distance, that is, the same data aggregate which
was already used by Yadava et. al. (2002). For
this purpose, a polynomial model is chosen to
applied here. A brief discussion about polynomial
model is given below:
A general expression of the
form
(Waerden, 1948)
where a0 is the constant term ;ai
is the coefficient of xi (i =1, 2,
3, ..., n) but a1, a2,...,
an are also constants but these belong
to a field (field means a nonempty set in which
group for addition, group for multiplication
and left as well as right distributive law hold)
and n is the positive integer,
is called a polynomial of degree n and the symbol
x is called an indeterminate.
An effort has been made here
to find out what types of models are more appropriate
to total marriage migration by distance in Comilla
of Bangladesh. Thus, the fundamental objectives
of this study are briefly mentioned below:
i) to build up mathematical models to total
marriage migration by distance and
ii) to apply cross-validity prediction power
(CVPP), ,
to the model to verify how much the model is
valid or not.
Sources of Data
The data on total marriage migration associated
with distance of Comilla district in Bangladesh
have been taken from Yadava et. al. (2002).
This data was also available in Hossain (2000)
and prohibited in Table 1.
Mathematical Model Fitting
Using the scattered plot of marriage migration
associated with distance of Bangladesh (Fig.
1), it is observed that marriage migration can
be fitted by polynomial model with respect to
distance. Therefore, an nth degree polynomial
model is considered and the form of the model
is
(Gupta and Kapoor, 1997)
where, x is distance; y is marriage migration;
is the constant; is the coefficient of (i =1,
2, 3, ..., n) and u is the stochastic error
term of the model. Here a suitable n has been
selected for which the error sum of square is
minimum.
The software STATISTICA was used to fit the
mathematical model.
Checking Model Validation
To check how much the model is stable, the cross
validity prediction power
(CVPP), ,
is applied. Here, ;
where, n is the number of cases, k = the number
of regressors in the model and the cross-validated
R is the correlation between observed and predicted
values of the dependent variable (Stevens, 1996).
The shrinkage of the model is the absolute value
of the difference of and R2. The
stability of R2 of this model is
equal to 1- shrinkage.
F-test
To verify the measure of the overall significance
of the fitted model as well as the significance
of R2, the F-test is employed to this model.
The formula for F-test in mathematics is as
follows:

where k is the number of parameters to be estimated,
n is the number of cases and R2 is
the coefficient of determination in the model
(Gujarati, 1998).
| APPLICATION
OF THE MODEL AND RESULTS |
The polynomial model is assumed for marriage
migration due to distance in Comilla of Bangladesh
and the fitted equation is
y = 1025.557-169.5126x+9.613215x2-0.182286x3
t-stats- (105.562) (-47.561) (27.80423) (-19.2117)
p-value- (0.000) (0.000) (0.00001) (0.0000)
providing R2=0.999714324 and =0.998875.
This is the polynomial of degree three i.e.
cubic polynomial.
From this statistics we see that the fitted
model is highly cross-validated and its shrinkage
is 0.000839. These imply that the fitted model
is 99.8875% stable. Moreover, all the parameters
of the fitted model are also highly statistically
significant with 99.9714324% of variance explained.
Moreover, the stability of R2 of this model
is also more than 99%.
In this study the calculated value of F-test
is 4665.96, that is, large quantity which means
that the fitted model is overall highly significant
at 1% level of significance. Therefore, from
these statistics we see that the fitted model
and corresponding R2 are highly statistically
significance. As a result, the model is good
fit. Thereafter, the prediction is dine and
the predicted values of the model are also demonstrated
in the last.
| Table
1 Distribution
of Marriage Migration Associated with Distance
of Comilla in Bangladesh |
| Distance (in miles) |
Number of Migrants |
Predicted Values |
| 0-3 |
792 |
792.3030 |
| 3-6 |
442 |
440.8074 |
| 6-9 |
219 |
218.0541 |
| 9-12 |
87 |
94.5130 |
| 12-15 |
48 |
40.6537 |
| 15-18 |
29 |
26.9459 |
| 18-21 |
18 |
23.8593 |
| 21-24 |
4 |
1.86360 |
Fig. 1 Observed and Fitted Marriage
Migration Associated with Distance of Comilla
in Bangladesh
In this paper it is found that third degree
polynomial model is fitted to the distribution
of marriage migration associated with distance
of Muslim community in Bangladesh. The results
show that this model is also applicable or suitable
even if Hossain fitted pareto exponential model
and Yadava et. al. showed that exponeutial distribution
provided better approximation than Hossain.
Hence it is concluded that the pattern of marriage
migration due to distance follow 3rd degree
polynomial model.
Gujarati, Damodar N. (1998). Basic Econometric,
Third Edition, McGraw Hill, Inc., New York.
Gupta, S. C. & Kapoor, V. K. (1997). Fundamentals
of Mathematical Statistics, Ninth Extensively
Revised Edition, Sultan Chand & Sons, Educational
Publishers, New Delhi.
Hossain, M.Z. (2000). Some Demographic Models
and their Applications with Special Reference
to Bangladesh. An Unpublished Ph. D. Thesis
in Statistics, Banaras Hindu University, Varanasi,
India.
Islam, Md. Rafiqul & Ali, M. Korban. (2004).
Mathematical Modeling of Age Specific Fertility
Rates and Study the Reproductivity in the Rural
Area of Bangladesh During 1980-1998, Pakistan
Journal of Statistics, Pakistan Vol. 20(3),
Page-381-394.
Libbee, M.J. and Sopher, D. E. (1975). Marriage
and Migration in Rural India. in Kosinski, L.A.
and Prothero, R.M. (eds.) People on the Move:
Studies on International, Migration, London:
Methuen and Company.
Morril, R. L. and Pitts, F.R. (1967). Marriage,
Migration and the Mean Information Field. Annals,
Association of American Geographers, 57, 401-22.
Perry, P. (1969a). Marriage Distance Relationsship
in North Otago 1975-1914. New Zealand's Geographers,
25(1), 36-43.
Perry, P. (1969b). Working class Isolation
and Mobility in Rural Dorset 1837-1936: A Study
of Marriage Distance, Trans. Inst. Brit. Geographers,
47, 121-140.
Samuel, M.J. (1994). Patterns of Female Migration,
In Maithili Vishwanathan (eds). Women and Society,
IV, Printwell, Jaipur, India.
Sharma, L. (1984). A Study of the Pattern of
Out-migration from Rural Areas. Unpublished
Ph. D. Thesis in Statistics, Banaras Hindu University.
India.
Stevens, J. (1996). Applied Multivariate Statistics
for the Social Sciences, Third Edition, Lawrence
Erlbaum Associates, Inc., Publishers, New Jersey.
Waerden, B.L.Van Der. (1948). Modern Algebra,
Vol. 1, ICK Ungar Publishing Co. New York.
Yadavs, K.N.S., Srivastava, Soni and Islam,
Sabina. (2002). Distribution of Distance Associated
with Marriage Migration, International Journal
of Statistical Sciences, Vol. 1, Dept. of Statistics,
University of Rajshahi, Bangladesh, Page 49-54.
Yadavs, K.N.S., Hossain, M.Z and Islam, Sabina
(1998). Distribution of Distance Associated
with Marriage Migration in Rural Areas of Bangladesh.
The Bangladesh Journal of Scientific Research,
16(2), 201-207.
Yadava. K.N. S. Raju, K.N.M. and Yadava, G.S.
(1988). On the Distribution of Distance Associated
with Marriage Migration in Rural Areas of Uttar
Pradesh. India. Rural Demography, XV (1), 7-18.
|