Utilization
of Postnatal Care in Al-Hassa, Saudi Arabia
.........................................................................................................................
Abdel-Hady El-Gilany (M.D., Public Health)(1)
and Sabry Hammad (M.D., Public Health)(2)
(1) College of Medicine in Al-Hassa, King Faisal
University, Saudi Arabia
(2) Ministry of Health, Saudi Arabia
Correspondence:
Abdel-Hady El-Gilany
Prof. of Public Health, College of Medicine,
Mansoura University, Egypt
Family and Community Medicine Department,
College of Medicine in Al-Hassa
King Faisal University
P.O. Box: 400
Hofuf 31982
Saudi Arabia
e-mail: ahgilany@hotmail.com
Mobile: 00966/566482385
|
ABSTRACT
Objectives:
To assess utilization of postnatal care
and to define the magnitude of postnatal
maternal morbidities in Al-Hassa, Saudi
Arabia.
Methods:
A descriptive study involved 1,996 mothers,
representing 94.7% of mothers giving birth
during a four months duration in the catchment
areas of 15 Primary Health Care Centers
(PHCCs) in urban, rural and hegar (deserts
collection) localities. Trained Arabic-speaking
nurses collected data from family files
and maternity cards kept at PHCCs as well
as by an interview with mothers, two months
after delivery, at infant vaccination
sessions.
Results:
Less than half of the mothers received
postnatal care, mostly (88.7%) at PHCCs.
Logistic regression analysis revealed
that the independent predictors of seeking
postnatal care were the presence of maternal
morbidities (OR=8.0), long pregnancy spacing
(OR=1.9) and antenatal care at private
clinic (OR= 1.3). No maternal mortality
was recorded in the chosen PHCCs during
the study period. About 5% of mothers
reported one or more postnatal morbidities.
The most frequent postnatal morbidity
was breast engorgement/abscess.
Conclusions:
Postnatal care coverage is low and is
often considered as unnecessary. Therefore,
there is an urgent need for an awareness-raising
program highlighting the importance and
availability of postnatal care. Antenatal
care visits are good opportunities to
counsel mothers about postnatal care.
Key words:
postnatal care - postnatal morbidities
- Saudi Arabia
|
The postpartum period or puerperium includes
the first six weeks after delivery of the placenta
[1-3]. This period is a very special phase in
the life of a woman. She is going through the
physiological process of uterine involution
and at the same time adapting to her new role
in the family. Many postpartum complications
occur during this period[1,2,4].
Among the important obstetric morbidities are
postpartum hemorrhage, pregnancy-related hypertension,
pulmonary embolism and puerperal sepsis. The
common surgical complications are wound breakdown,
breast abscess and urinary fecal incontinence.
Medical conditions such as anemia, headache,
backache, constipation and sexual problems may
also be present[2,3].
Postpartum care is the most neglected aspect
of maternity care and more research is needed
on issues related to postpartum maternal health.
Early postpartum care is essential to diagnose
and treat complications[5]. Although
there is little evidence to support the timing
and content of postpartum visits, there is evidence
that this is a time of increased health needs
for both mother and baby[6]. Postpartum
care visits provide opportunities to assess
the physical and psychological well-being of
the mother, counsel her on infant care and family
planning and give appropriate referrals for
pre-existing or developing chronic conditions[4,5,7].
Utilization of reproductive health services,
including maternal health care, is related to
their availability, and socioeconomic, demographic
and cultural factors such as women's age, education,
employment and autonomy; and perception of women
and their families regarding the need for care[8-10].
In contrast to relatively high to moderate levels
of antenatal care received by women in the Arab
region, the coverage of postnatal care is markedly
lower[11]. In other regions of Saudi
Arabia postnatal care coverage ranged from a
very low rate of 6.5% in the Northern Region[12]
(12) and up to 52% in Abha Region[13].
Postnatal care coverage ranged from 48-88% at
the national level, according to different surveys[14,15].
This study aims to assess utilization of postnatal
care and to define the magnitude of postnatal
maternal morbidities in Al-Hassa, Saudi Arabia.
This study was carried out in Al-Hassa, Saudi
Arabia, during a period of four months from
February 1 to the end of May 2007 G. Al-Hassa
is located in the Eastern Zone of the Kingdom,
bordering the Arabian Gulf. It is an agricultural
area. The population is estimated to be about
800 thousands, distributed into urban, rural
and hegar (Bedouin desert collections). Maternity
care is provided through a network of 47 PHCCs,
maternal and child hospitals, two small district
hospitals in addition to the private sector
and National Guard hospital and health centers.
After selection of PHCCs and nomination of
nurses, the questionnaire was developed and
pretested on 150 mothers (10 from each of the
15 PHCCs) to train nurses on data collection,
reveal any difficulties and to estimate the
percentage of mothers who received postnatal
care. The pilot study revealed that it is necessary
to review maternity cards and family files in
addition to the interview with mothers.
The sample size was calculated using Epi Info
2004 software. From statistics of Al-Hassa Directorate
of Health 15032 births were registered during
2006 G. With an expected postnatal care coverage
of 51% from the pilot study, confidence interval
of 95% and power of 80%, the number of mothers
required was 1394. To overcome the attrition
due to cluster sampling methodology, 30% were
added. Thus, the final sample was 1812 mothers.
This sample was distributed proportionally to
urban, rural and Hegar localities.
Two-stage stratified sampling technique was
used. The first stage is stratification of Al-Hassa
into urban, rural and Hegar areas. At the second
stage, five primary health care centers (PHCCs)
were chosen from each stratum. These centers
were chosen based on availability of an Arabic
speaking nurse and their geographical distribution
to represent different socioeconomic strata
of the community.
Mothers were assured that data collected would
be dealt with confidentially and the impact
of the study would be respected, maintained
and used only for research purposes and for
improving services. Al-Hassa Directorate of
Health approved the study and questionnaire
and mothers gave verbal consent before the interview.
There is no ethical research committee at the
moment.
An Arabic speaking female nurse completed the
questionnaires during interview with mothers
two months after birth during a vaccination
session in each center. Additional data was
abstracted from both family file, maternity
cards and hospital discharge forms kept in a
family file at PHCCs. A maternity card has been
developed to include the appropriate data on
prenatal, natal and postnatal care, as well
as a list of factors of high-risk pregnancy
for referral purposes and maternal morbidities.
The Ministry of Health has developed special
guidelines for using the card, explaining its
contents and how to use it, as well as defining
the various measurements and investigation and
their normal limits. It is shared by the health
centers and hospital. There is continuous stress
on completeness of this card.
The outcome variable is receiving one or more
postnatal check ups by a health care personnel,
whatever its source.
Data were analyzed using SPSS (Statistical
Package for Social Sciences) version 11. Descriptive
statistics were done. The chi-squared test was
used to find significance between categorical
variables. Significant predictors of receiving
postnatal care in univariate analysis were entered
into multivariate stepwise forward Wald logistic
regression analysis. Odds ratios and their 95%
confidence intervals were presented. P=0.05
was considered statistically significant.
The study covered 94.7% (1996 out of 2108)
of mothers who gave birth in the catchment areas
of 15 primary health care centers during the
study duration. No maternal mortality was recorded.
Table 1 reveals that more than 50% of mothers
never received postnatal care and PHC centers
were the most common source of care. There was
no postnatal home visit. The main reasons for
not seeking postnatal care were absence of health
problems, busy husbands, the false idea that
postnatal care is not necessary (Table 2).
Table 3 shows that mothers with long pregnancy
spacing, mothers who received antenatal care
at private clinics, and gave birth at private
clinics and those with postnatal morbidities
are more likely to receive postnatal care. Logistic
regression analysis revealed that the independent
predictors of seeking postnatal care are presence
of postnatal morbidities, prolonged pregnancy
spacing and seeking care at private clinics
(Table 4).
The commonest postpartum morbidities were breast
engorgement/abscess (4.1) and infected episiotomy/
perineal tear (1.9%) (Table 5).
| Table
(1) Coverage and facility providing
postnatal care |
|
|
Number (%) |
Postnatal care:
None
One visit
Two visits |
1001(50.2)
964(48.3)
31(1.6) |
Facility
providing postnatal care†:
Primary health care centers
Private clinics
Governmental hospitals
Shared care‡ |
883(88.7)
86(8.6)
14(1.4)
12(1.2) |
Among 995 mothers seeking postnatal care.
shared care between PHCC, hospital and/or
private clinics.
| Table
(2) Reasons for not seeking postnatal
care |
|
Reason |
Number (%)† |
No health
problems
False
idea that postnatal care is not necessary
No
female physicians at PHCCs
Too busy mother or husbands
Overcrowded clinics/long waiting time
Others(not at usual residence, unsuitable
working hours, PHCC is far away) |
511(51.0)
316(31.6)
217(21.7)
179(17.9)
102(10.2)
38(3.8) |
Among 1001 mothers not seeking postnatal
care and categories are not mutually exclusive.
| Table
(3) Univariate analysis of predictors
of seeking postnatal care |
|
Predictors |
Total N (%) |
Postnatal care N (%) |
OR(95%CI) |
|
Total |
1996(100) |
995(49.8) |
|
Residence:
Urban
Rural
Hegar |
971(48.6)
799(40.0)
226(11.3) |
488(50.3)
408(51.1)
99(43.8) |
1(r)
1.0(0.9-1.3)
0.8(0.6-1.0) |
Family income:
Satisfactory
Unsatisfactory |
1589(79.6)
407(20.4) |
790(49.7)
205(50.4) |
1(r)
1.0(0.8-1.3) |
Distance from PHCC:
Up to 1 km
> 1 Km |
1142(57.2)
854(29.3) |
568(49.7)
427(50.0) |
1(r)
1.0(0.8-1.2) |
Family size:
5 or less
> 5 |
1157(58.0)
839(42.0) |
556(48.1)
439(52.3) |
1(r)
1.2(0.99-1.4) |
Maternal
education: Illiterate/Primary
Preparatory
Secondary
Above secondary |
482(24.1)
267(13.4)
756(37.9)
491(24.6) |
249(51.7)
136(50.9)
363(48.0)
247(50.3) |
1(r)
1.0(0.7-1.3)
0.9(0.7-1.1)
1.0(0.7-1.2) |
Maternal work:
House wife
Work outside home
Student |
1669(83.6)
206(10.3)
121(6.1) |
836(50.1)
108(52.4)
51(42.1) |
1(r)
1.1(0.8-1.5)
0.7(0.5-1.1) |
Husband's
education: Illiterate/Primary
Preparatory
Secondary
Above secondary |
406(20.3)
429(21.5)
696(34.9)
465(23.3) |
198(48.8)
232(54.1)
327(47.0)
238(51.2) |
1(r)
1.2(0.9-1.6)
0.9(0.7-1.2)
1.1(0.8-1.5) |
Husband's
work: Professional/semiprof
Police/military
Trades/business
Others |
653(32.7)
387(19.4)
411(20.6)
545(27.3) |
330(50.5)
189(48.8)
195(47.4)
281(51.6) |
1(r)
0.9(0.7-1.2)
0.9(07-1.1)
1.0(0.8-1.3) |
Maternal age:
<20 years
20-35 years
35 & more |
96(4.8)
1561(78.2)
339(17.0) |
41(42.7)
770(49.3)
184(54.3) |
1(r)
1.3(0.8-2.0)
1.6(1.0-2.9) |
Gravidity:
Primigravida
2 & 3
4 & more |
481(24.1)
664(33.3)
851(42.6) |
225(46.8)
315(47.4)
455(53.5) |
1(r)
1.0(0.8-1.3)
1.3(1.0-1.7) |
Spacing†:
<1 year
1-3 years
> 3 years |
409(20.5)
784(39.3)
322(16.1) |
179(43.8)
383(48.9)
208(64.3) |
1(r)
1.2(1.0-1.6)
2.3(1.7-3.2)*** |
Antenatal care attendance
No
Yes |
46(2.3)
1950(97.7) |
27(58.7)
968(49.6) |
1(r)
0.7(0.4-1.3) |
Antenatal care at private clinic##
No
Yes |
1328(68.1)
622(31.9) |
613(46.2)
355(57.1) |
1(r)
1.6(1.3-1.9)*** |
Birth at private clinic:
No
Yes |
1685(84.4)
311(15.6) |
827(49.1)
168(54.0) |
1(r)
1.2(0.95-1.6) |
Postnatal morbidity:
No
Yes |
1889(94.6)
107(5.4) |
900(47.6)
95(88.8) |
1(r)
8.7(4.6-16.8)*** |
Primigravidae were excluded, ## Non-attenders
for antenatal care were excluded.
*** P£0.001
| Table
(4) Multivariate logistic regression
analysis of significant predictors of seeking
postnatal care |
|
Predictor |
No postnatal care |
|
b |
P |
OR(95% CI) |
Spacing*:
<1 year
1-3 years
> 3 years |
-0.1
0.6 |
0.4
0.000 |
1(r)
0.9(0.7-1.1)
1.9(1.4-2.4) |
Antenatal care at private clinic:
No
Yes |
-
0.3 |
-
0.004 |
1(r)
1.3(1.1-1.6) |
Postnatal morbidity:
No
Yes |
-
2.1 |
0.000 |
1(r)
8.0(4.4-14.8) |
Constant
Percent
correctly predicated
Model c² |
-0.3
57.6
118.4,P=0.000
|
OR= Odds ratio, CI= Confidence Interval, r=
reference group
| Table
(5) Postnatal morbidities reported |
|
|
Number (%) |
Any morbidity
Breast abscess/engorgement
Urinary
tract infection
Infected
episiotomy/perineal tear
Postpartum
hemorrhage
Postpartum
depression
Postpartum fits
Others† |
107(5.4)
68(3.4)
41(2.1)
31(1.6)
23(1.2)
2(0.1)
1(0.05)
36(1.8) |
e.g. piles, varicose veins, pneumonia, umbilical
hernia, gastro-enteritis and severe constipation
Currently, the primary health care program
of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia has become well
established, with the attainment of a very wide
coverage. Maternal care is the responsibility
of physicians assisted by the nurse and midwives[14].
Health care services provided by the governmental
sector in Saudi Arabia account for over 80%
of total services and are almost provided free
of charge. Health care is also provided by other
agencies e.g. National Guard, ARAMCO Petroleum
Company and the private sector[15].
Like antenatal care, the postpartum care that
typically occurs during the six weeks after
childbirth is considered important to a new
mother' health. Unlike the tracking of prenatal
visits, however, few statistics exists on postpartum
health care utilization or postpartum health
problems. Thus, postpartum care is a neglected
aspect of women's health care[16,17].
About half of mothers received postnatal care;
most of them attended once and only 1.6% attended
twice to the health facility; there were no
home visits. Reasons cited for not seeking postnatal
care were mainly absence of health problems,
and no need for care, mother's ignorance about
the importance of postnatal care as well as
busy husbands. This relatively high rate of
postnatal check-up may be attributed to the
policy followed in some PHCC that mothers should
attend for check-up as a pre-requisite for registration
of newborns. This is evident from the finding
that most mothers received a postnatal check-up
at the PHCC. Mothers attending postnatal care
at hospitals and private clinics are most probably
those with morbidities necessitating specialist
consultation or hospitalization. Further evidence
is that presence of postnatal morbidities is
the strongest independent predictor of receiving
postnatal care in general.
This coverage rate is much higher than the
rate of 6.5% reported from the Northern Region
of the Kingdom[12]. However, it is
lower than the 52% coverage reported from Abha
Region[13]. Review of the data from
the Saudis National mothers and child health
surveys of 1987 and 1990 showed that the percentage
of mothers who received postnatal care increased
from 58% to 88%[14]. Rates of postnatal
care from other developing countries were reported
to be 34% in Nepal[18], 33% in India
and 84% in Zambia. In USA, 98% of mothers participated
in a Pregnancy Risk Assessment Monitoring System
received postnatal care[7].
It was reported that lack of awareness is the
main barrier to the utilization of postnatal
care. Women's own occupation, number of pregnancies,
children, and husbands' socioeconomic status,
occupation and education were significantly
associated with the utilization of postnatal
care[7,18]. In Saudi Arabia, there
are a lot of problems concerning the understanding
of postnatal care home visits:
- the mother and her family do not realize
the need for postnatal care,
- traditionally, because of fear of the evil
eye, nobody is allowed to see the mother or
her baby,
- many health staff are expatriate who do
not understand the language or local customs,
so they are not accepted at home level,
- problems regarding the need for somebody
to accompany a female to home in addition
to the driver,
- transport may not be available for home
visits,
- male doctors find it difficult to examine
female patients,
- delivery may take place at home, in other
region or in a private clinic without communication
with health centers,
- nursing staff may face isolated, unforeseen
bad experiences at home level and (9) home
visits are less likely and may not be welcomed
for cultural reasons[21].
In Saudi Arabia, women are not allowed to drive
cars so husbands or other adult male family
members need to accompany her to the health
centre.
Maternal morbidity refers to complications
that have arisen during pregnancy, delivery
or the past-partum period[19]. Postpartum
morbidities continue to be major health issues
that need to be looked into critically, not
only for curative but also for preventive and
promotive care[22]. About 5.4 % of
mothers reported one or more severe postnatal
morbidities. A higher percentage of mothers
with postnatal morbidities, up to 42.9%, was
reported from other countries[23,24].
The commonest morbidities encountered were
breast abscess/engorgement, infected episiotomy/perineal
tear and urinary tract infection. In the Northern
region urinary tract infection, puerperal sepsis
and postpartum hemorrhage were the commonest
postnatal morbidities(12). In the Saudi Arabia
Family and Health, about 7% and 6% of respondents
reported having severe bleeding and fever, respectively,
after delivery[15]. In other countries,
the main disorders for which postpartum women
sought care were puerperal sepsis, secondary
postpartum hemorrhage and postpartum eclampsia.
The commonest cause of sepsis was infected episiotomies
or tears[19,22-24].
In conclusion, postnatal care is deficient
in coverage and number of visits. To improve
postnatal care there is a need to establish
adequate outreach services in catchment areas.
PHC staff should routinely trace defaulting
mothers through telephone communication or home
visits. Importance of postnatal visits should
be communicated to all women at the time of
antenatal care and discharge from the hospital
after delivery. The policy of obligatory postnatal
check-up as a pre-requisite to register of newborns
implemented in PHCC can be generalized to all
health centers. A clear policy about quality,
number, timing and contents of postnatal check-ups
will contribute to increase postnatal care coverage.
In-depth qualitative study is warranted to explore
the socio-cultural and behavioral factors impeding
postnatal care.
- WHO. Postpartum care of mother and newborn
: a practical guide. World Health Organization,
Geneva. 1998
- Blenning CE, Pladine H. An Approach to
the postpartum office visit. Am Fam Physician
2005;72(12):2443-4
- Zainur RZ, Loh KY. Postpartum morbidity-what
we can do? Med J Malaysia 2006;61(5):651-6
- Liu N, Mao L, Sun X, Liu X, Chen B, Ding
Q. Postpartum practices of puerperal women
and their influencing factors in three regions
of Hubei, China. BMC Public Health 2006;6:274
- Ghai OP. Reproductive Health. In: Gupta
P, Ghai OP (eds) Textbook of preventive and
social medicine, 2nd edn. 2007 P.347
- Gunn J, Lumley J, Young D. Involvement
of Victorian general practitioners in obstetric
and postnatal care. Aust Fam Physician 1998;27(Suppl.2)
S73-83
- CDC (Center for Disease Control). Postpartum
care visits-11 States and New York City, 2004.
MMWR 2007;56(50):1312-1316
- Addai I. Determinants of use of maternal
and child health services in rural Ghana.
J Biosoc Sci 2000;32:1-15
- Acharya LB, Cleland J. Maternal and child
health services in rural Nepal: does access
or quality matter more. Health Policy Planning
2000;15(2):223-229
- International Institute for Population
Sciences. National family survey, 1998-99.
International Institute for Population Sciences,
Mumbai, India. 2000
- Nawar L. Reproductive health and reproductive
rights in the Arab Region. Background paper
presented to the Arab Population Forum. Beirut,
November 19-21, 2004
- El-Gilany AH, Al-Hozem N, Aref Y. Maternity
care in primary health care centers, Northern
Region, Saudi Arabia. Saudi J Obstet Gynecol
2002; 2(3):99-112
- Abu-Zeid HA. Health services utilization
patterns of two urban communities in Abha,
Saudi Arabia. J Community Health 1989;14(2):65-77
- Baldo MH. Maternal health care. In: Quality
assurance in primary health care manual, Ministry
of Health, Saudi Arabia. EMRO-WHO. 1st edn.
1994
- Khoja TA, Farid SM. (eds). Saudi Family
health Survey 1996, Ministry of Health, Saudi
Arabia. Preliminary Report. 1997
- Albers LL. Health Problems after childbirth.
J Midwifery and Women's Health 2000;45:55-57
- Cheng C, Fowles ER, Walker LO. Postpartum
maternal health care in the United States:
A critical review. J Perinatal Educ 2006;15(3):34-42
- Dhakal S, Champan GN, Simkhada PP, VanTeijlingen
ER, Stephens J, Raja AE. Utilization of postnatal
care among rural women in Nepal. BMC Pregnancy
and Childbirth 2007;7:19
- Vallely L, Ahmed Y, Murray S. Postpartum
maternal morbidity requiring hospital admission
in Lusaka, Zambia - a descriptive study. BMC
Pregnancy and Childbirth 2005;5:1-8
- Yesudian PP. Impact of women's empowerment,
autonomy and attitude on maternal health care
utilization in India. International Institute
for Population Sciences. Global Forum for
Health Research. Forum 8. Mixico City. 2004
- Ministry of Health, Saudi Arabia. Maternal
and child health services manual for health
centers physicians. 2nd edn. El-Hilal Press,
Riyadh. 1997:25-99
- Shakuntala C, Varma SP, Ritambara B. Quality
of postpartum care. J Obstet Gynaecol India
2006;56:142-145
- Bang RA, Bang AT, Reddy MH, Deshmuskh MD,
Baitule SB, Fillippi V. Maternal morbidity
during labor and the puerperium in rural homes
and the need for medical attention: a prospective
observational study in Gadchiroli, India.
Br J Obstet Gynaecol 2004;111:231-238
- Brace V, Penney G, Hall M. Quantifying
severe maternal morbidity: a Scottish population
study. Br J Obstet Gynaecol 2004;111(5):481-484
|