Utilization
of Maternal Health Care Services in Bangladesh:
Evidence from Bangladesh Demographic and Health
Survey 2000-2004
.........................................................................................................................
Md. Mosiur Rahman1,
Md. Golam Mostafa1 and Dr. Md. Nurul
Islam2
Institutions
- Department of Population Science and
Human Resource Development, University of
Rajshahi, Rajshahi-6205, Bangladesh.
- Department of Statistics, University of
Rajshahi, Rajshahi-6205, Bangladesh.
|
ABSTRACT
Maternal
health, especially in the pregnancy period,
is a worthy researchtopic. Less developed
countries like Bangladesh give little
attention to the utilization of mother’s
health care services. This study investigates
the utilization of maternal and child
health care in Bangladesh, using data
from the 2004 Bangladesh Demographic and
Health survey (BDHS, 2004) vover 2 eperiod
spaning 1990-1999 and 2000-2004. The analysis
reveals that a vast majority of women
do not take any care (i.e., antenatal.
natal and postnatal care services) and
of those women who take antenatal care
most of them received care from doctors
and the same result is obtained for the
time span 1990-1999 and 2000-2004. Well-trained
personnel can reduce mother and child
mortality at the time of the delivery.
This study also found that very few women
in Bangladesh are found to receive delivery
assistance from medically trained personnel
and most of them took assistance from
untrained persons. It is also observed
from the study that around nineteen percent
of mother’s place of delivery is their
own homes or other homes and only a few
of them were found to go to the government
or private hospital for delivery cases.
This study also elucidates that only 12
percent of babies receive a postnatal
checkup by trained health providers within
the first two days of delivery. Although
it is found that in the time span 1990-1999
and 2000-2004 a vast portion of the children
aged 12-23 months receive all the recommended
vaccination before their first birthday
but still many of them did not receive
the recommended vaccination.
Key words:
Ante natal care, Natal care, Post natal
care, Pregnancy complications, Delivery
assistance.
|
Maternal
health services have been given highest priority
in the health system and it deserves high priority
and special importance in a nation’s development.
In any community, mothers constitute not only
a relatively large and primary group, but also
a vulnerable or special risk group. The risk
is connected especially with child bearing and
delivery. Globally, over half a million women
die of pregnancy related complications each
year and 99 percent of these deaths occur in
developing countries (ICPD, 1994; UNICEF, 1996).
UNFPA has estimated lifetime risk of dying from
pregnancy and child birth related causes in
Bangladesh as 1 woman in 21, which compares
to 1 woman in over 4,000 in industrialized countries
(UNFPA, 2002). The situation in South Asia is
more precarious and accounts for about half
of maternal deaths, globally (WHO, 1991). In
Bangladesh, the current level of maternal mortality
is very high, even by the standard of other
developing countries (Mtra al., 1994). Much
of the maternal mortality and morbidity is largely
preventable and improvement of maternal health
considerably contributes to the health of general
population. These considerations have led to
the formulation of special health care services
for mothers all over the world. The term ‘Maternal
Health Care’ encompasses the promotive, preventive,
curative and rehabilitative health care for
mothers especially during and after the pregnancy
and delivery. The provision of maternal health
care services is of utmost importance for the
survival as well as for a better health and
better quality of life of both mother and child.
The
state of maternal health in a nation can be
characterized by numerous factors, such as outcome
measures like maternal mortality and morbidity
rates, or maternal nutrition status, as well
as process indicators of service availability
and use. These indicators include: the levels
of antenatal and postnatal care, contraceptive
prevalence rate (CPR), coverage of tetanus toxoid
(TT) vaccination, proportion of deliveries conducted
in health facilities by trained birth attendants,
or proportion of unwanted pregnancies. Unfortunately,
according to many of these measures, the maternal
health situation in Bangladesh appears to be
poor. Antenatal care is essential to promote,
protect and maintain the health of both mother
and child The risk of maternal mortality and
morbidity as well as neonatal deaths and infant
mortality and morbidity can be reduced substantially
through proper antenatal care, such as timely
regular antenatal check-ups to trained health
personal during pregnancy and delivery under
safe and hygienic condition (Moller et al.,
1989; Joseph, 1989). Three visits should be
covered during the entire pregnancy a) 1st
visit at 20 weeks or as soon as the pregnancy
is known, b) 2nd visit at 32 weeks
and c) 3rd visits at 36 weeks. (Park,
1997).
In Bangladesh, lack of proper medical attention
and hygienic conditions during delivery leads
to the risk of complications and infections
that cause death or serious illness for the
mother or the newborn or both. Although Government
health facilities are available down to union
level, more than 90% of deliveries are conducted
at home (BDHS, 1999-2000).
Despite the presence of a well-established
service delivery infrastructure in Bangladesh
and various measures taken so far, the utilization
of essential obstetric care (EmOC) services
is still poor. Women in rural Bangladesh are
not fully aware of the complications that they
may encounter during pregnancy and childbirth,
and even those who are aware do not know where
to go for help. They also face certain barriers
(cultural, geographic and economic) in accessing
obstetric care. Although the problem is not
exclusively medical, the role of the health
system is most crucial to the saving of lives.
A large percentage of women with obstetric complications
fail to get the care they need in time and die
at home or on the way to the hospital. This
is because referral linkage in the country is
weak and there is a need to strengthen it from
the grassroots level to the upper tiers of service
delivery (Ahmed S et al., 1998).
Although Bangladesh has made significant
progress in child survival initiatives and has
cut the infant mortality rate by half, every
year 150,000 babies are lost within the first
28 days of their lives. Added to this loss,
another 100,000 babies are stillborn in late
pregnancy bringing the total perinatal (still
births and early neonatal) and neonatal deaths
to 250,000 annually.
Hence from the forgoing analysis it appears
that although Maternal and Child Health (MCH)
services have been given highest priority in
the health sector the maternal health situation
in Bangladesh appears to be poor and the facilities
available for these services is not sufficient
enough to fulfill these needs adequately.
Maternal
Health Care Delivery System in Bangladesh
Maternal and child health (MCH) services
have been given highest priority in the health
system. At the community level the services are
provided by the Family Welfare Assistants and
Health Assistants from the Community Clinics (CC).
At the union level a Family Welfare Visitor (FWV)
and a Sub-Assistant Community Medical Officer
or Medical Assistants are mainly responsible for
providing the services. There are also 250 Graduate
Medical Officers posted in 3,275 UHFWCs for providing
MCH services. At the Upazila level, the MCH unit
of the Upazila Health Complex (UHC) headed by
a Graduate Medical Officer is responsible for
providing MCH services. Trained support personnel
such as FWV and Ayas (female ward assistants)
assist as well. There is also a position of junior
Consultant (Gynecological) who provides services
in case of emergencies, attending all deliveries
at the UHC and all referred maternal patients.
The activities of the MCH unit and other maternal
health care services are supervised by the Upazila
Health and Family Planning Officer in the UHC.
The MCWCs established mainly at the district
level (with some also at the Upazila level)
provide only the maternal and child health services
under the direct control of the Directorate
of Family Planning. These facilities are expected
to be equipped to provide basic EOC and obstetric
first aid (Ahmed et al., 1995). The District
Hospitals (DHs) in the district headquarters
provide maternal services through an outpatient
consultation centre and a labour ward. Between
25-40% hospital beds are reserved for maternal
patients in every hospital.
The immunization and other related programmes
such as health laboratory; epidemiological surveillance/health
information system will be further expanded
and strengthened to assist in controlling communicable
and non-communicable diseases effectively. A
typical THC is a two-story building and is headed
by a Thana Health and Family Planning Officer
(TH&FPO). Under TH&FPO there are 8 doctors
(the medical officers) working in each THC.
The THC covers on average a population of around
200,000 people. The lowest level of static health
facilities is located at Union level.
| Data
Collection and Methodology |
In Bangladesh, for women in reproductive age,
getting proper maternal health care services
was found to be beyond their reach, which is
mainly due to their poverty, illiteracy, general
backwardness and adherence to superstitious
beliefs, and inadequate facilities. With a view
to understanding the utilization of Maternal
and Child Health care Services (MCH) and its
determinants, this study has been carried out.
This study utilizes the data extracted from
2004 Bangladesh Demographic and Health Survey
(BDHS), which were conducted under the authority
of the National Institute of Population Research
and Training (NIPORT) of the Ministry of Health
and Family Welfare.
The BDHS survey was implemented by Mitra and
Associates, a private research firm located
in Dhaka. Macro International Inc. of Calverton,
Maryland provided technical assistance to the
project as a part of its international Demographic
and Health Survey (DHS) program, while financial
assistance was provided by United States Agency
for International Development (USAID) Bangladesh.
Previously, BDHS surveys were carried out in
1993-1994, 1996-1997 and 1999-2000.The objectives
of the BDHS was to provide up to date information
on fertility, childhood mortality, fertility
preference, awareness, approval and use of family
planning method, breastfeeding practices, nutrition
levels, maternal and child health and so forth.
This information is intended to assist in evaluating
and designing programmers’ strategies for improving
health and family planning services in Bangladesh.
The BDHS 2004 is a nationally representative
survey from 11,440 ever married women of age
10-49 and 4297 men age 15-54 from 10,500 households
covering 361 sample points (clusters) throughout
Bangladesh, 122 urban areas and 239 in the rural
areas. The data was collected from six administrative
divisions of the country - Barisal, Chittagong,
Dhaka, Khulna, Rajshahi and Sylhet. Data collection
took place over a five-month period from 1 January
to 25 May 2004. Out of 11,440 ever-married sample,
data was taken from8860 women who have at least
one child (live or dead) under consideration
the time interval 1990-2004 and divided the
sample according to the two time spans 1990-1999
and 2000-20004 in order to achieve our objectives.
In the time span 1990-1999, 3987 samples were
identified and in 2000-2004, 4873 were identified.
The data were analyzed using SPSS (Version 11.5).
Percentage distribution and the average value
are used to investigate the overall situation
of maternal and child health care utilization
in Bangladesh.
Findings
Background of the Respondents
The socio-economic and demographic background
of the women is presented in terms of their
educational status, occupational status, place
of residence, region of residence; mother’s
earning status and number of children surviving.
We have utilized respondents’ place of
residence as a proxy to control for the differing
levels of service access seen between urban
and rural areas. It is found that 26.5 percent
are in urban area and 73.5 percent live in rural
areas. The biggest percent of mothers live in
rural areas. The results in Table 2 provides
that Dhaka division contains the highest proportion
of mothers (31.9 percent), and more than one-quarter
lives in Rajshahi division compared to the other
division.
| Table 1: Socio-economic
and Demographic Background of Respondents |
|
Variable |
Percentage |
| 1990-1999 |
2000-2004 |
|
Place of residence
Urban
Rural
|
23.6
76.4 |
26.5
73.5 |
Region of residence
Barisal
Chittagong
Dhaka
Khulna
Rajshahi
Sylhet |
6.6
16.1
31.1
12.1
28.6
5.5 |
6.0
17.9
31.9
11.2
29.5
7.5 |
Religion
Muslim
Non-Muslim |
88.6
11.4 |
91.9
8.1 |
Mother’s education
No-education
Primary
Secondary
Higher |
49.5
30.2
17.0
3.3 |
36.5
30.3
27.7
5.5 |
Mother’s earning status
Not working
Working for cash
Others |
71.6
23.9
4.5 |
82.1
14.8
3.1 |
Husband’s education
No-education
Primary
Secondary
Higher |
41.4
25.8
23.4
9.4 |
39.2
26.8
24.2
9.9 |
Child survival
Status
Alive
Death |
94.5
5.5 |
95.4
4.6 |
|
|
|
|
Another structural variable included
here is religion. Religion is represented by
a dummy variable for Muslims and Non-Muslims.
Muslim women are expected to differ in receiving
health care services due to their restricted
movement and cultural norm than the Non-Muslim.
The analysis reveals that of a total group of
mothers 91.9 percent are Muslims.
The educational attainment of the women
was grouped into three categories (no education,
primary, secondary and higher education) so
as to capture critical educational transitions,
which are directly related to employment prospects,
and socioeconomic status. A large proportion
of mothers (36.5 percent) of the children are
illiterate. 27.6 percent completed secondary
education and only a few (5.5 percent) are higher
educated. Mothers are further distinguished
according to their work status.
A majority of the Bangladeshi women are
housewife (82.1 percent) and 14.8 percent are
involved in working with cash. Men with higher
educational attainment may play a more important
role in decisions affectng children than men
with less schooling (Caldwell, 1990). Our present
study represents that 39.2 percent women’s husbands
are illiterate and 9.9 percent are higher educated.
Regarding child survival status overall 95.4
percent are alive.
Ante Natal Care
Ante natal aspects such as, Antenatal
care (ANC) received Sources of
Antenatal care Number of months pregnant at
time of first visits, Number of antenatal visits,Tetanus
toxoid injection received; Delivery assistance;
are covered in the study.
| Table 2: Utilization of
Ante Natal Care Services according two-time
span 1990-1999 & 2000-2004 |
|
Characteristics
|
Percentage |
| |
1990-1999 |
2000-2004 |
|
Antenatal
care (ANC) received
Sufficient
a
Insufficient
b
No
care c
|
45.3
7.4
47.3
|
49.1
7.2
43.8
|
|
Sources
of Antenatal care
Government
Health professional
Doctor
Nurse/Trained midwife & Family welfare
visitor
TBA
Birth
attendant (trained & untrained)
Others
No one
|
27.2
18.1
0.2
7.2
47.3
|
31.6
19.5
0.3
4.8
43.8
|
|
Number
of months pregnant at time of first visits
<
6 months
6-7
months
8+
months
|
81.4
12.6
6.0
|
78.5
11.7
9.8
|
|
Number
of antenatal visits
None
For
one time
2-3
times
4
times or more
|
47.3
14.7
24.3
13.7
|
47.3
16.2
23.8
16.2
|
|
Tetanus
toxoid injection received
None
One
dose
Two/
more doses
|
17.3
22.6
60.1
|
18.4
26.0
55.6
|
|
Delivery
assistance
Medically
trained personnel d
TBA
e
Others
f
|
15.4
44.4
40.2
|
25.1
40.9
34.0
|
|
Vitamin-A
Received by
Mothers
Yes
No
Don’t
know
|
85.6
13.6
0.8
|
67.1
32.0
1.0
|
a.
Received at least three antenatal car visits
with first visit during the first three months
of pregnancy from medically trained personnel
(i.e. doctor, nurse & family welfare visitors).
b.
Received antenatal care from other persons (i.e.
trained & untrained TBA, other).
c.
Not receiving antenatal care.
d.
Assistance from doctor, nurse & family welfare
visitor
e.
Assistance from trained & untrained traditional
birth attendant
f.
Assistance from relative/other persons or no
one.
Antenatal care is the most important care for
a pregnant mother and her child in maternal
health services. Here in our maternal health
care services, we have categorized antenatal
care into three groups (groups are: Sufficient,
Insufficient & No care) depending on the
extent of care received by mothers. The mothers
who received the antenatal care visits from
medically trained personal (i.e. doctor, nurse
& family welfare visitor) are treated as
sufficient antenatal care. The mothers who didn’t
receive antenatal care from medically trained
personal are treated as insufficient antenatal
care and the mothers who didn’t receive any
type of antenatal care are considering in the
none category or No care. Representing in this
way we see from Table 2, that 45.3 percent of
mothers take sufficient antennal care and only
7.4 percent of mothers take insufficient antenatal
care and the rest of the 47.3 percent women
did not have any care during 1990-1999. On the
other side during 2000-2004, sufficient antenatal
care was taken by 49.1 percent of mothers and
only 7.2 percent of mothers had taken insufficient
and the rest of 43.8 percent mother dud not
have any type of care.


Table 2 represents mothers who have sufficient
antenatal care, 27.2 percent have care from
doctor, and 18.1 percent from nurses or trained
midwifes and family welfare visitors and 47.3
percent did not have any care from any persons
in 1990-1999 (Figure-1). On the other side,
from 2000-2004, the rate of antenatal care from
doctors has increased than in 1990-1999, where
31.6 percent mothers had gone to the doctor
and 19.5 percent to nurse/trained midwife and
family welfare visitors and 43.8 percent did
not have any care (Figure-2). Antenatal visits
should be taken in the specific months during
pregnancy. It can also be seen from Table 2
it is clear that most of the mothers (81.4 percent)
had the first visit within six months, 12.6
percent of mothers visitedwithin six to seven
months and only 6.0 percent mother had care
in eight months or after (1990-1999). In 2000-2004,
78.4 percent and 11.7 percent mothers had a
visit less than six months, and six to seven
months respectively. Only a few, 9.8 percent
of mother had it in eight months or after eight
months during pregnancy.
We can see that Table 2 represents that 14.7
percent, 24.3 percent and 13.7 percent of mothers
had taken one, 2-3 or more than 4 antenatal
visits and 47.3 percent of mothers did not have
any visits, respectively in 1990-1999. On the
other hand in 2000-2004 16.2 percent, 23.8 percent
and 16.2 percent mothers made visits for one,
two or three times and more than four times
respectively.
In the case of tetanus toxoid (TT) injection,
the mothers’ who have received two or more dose
of TT injections are considered in one group.
The other categories are those who have received
just one dose and the rest is those who haven’t
received any dose of TT injection. On this view
17.3 percent of mothers did not take any dose,
22.6 percent mother had taken only one dose
and 60.1 percent mother had taken two or more
doses of tetanus toxoid (TT) injections in 1990-1999.
Besides these 26.0 percent of mothers had taken
one dose, 55.6 percent had taken two or more
doses and 18.4 percent of mothers did not take
any dose in 2000-2004.
Well-trained personnel can reduce a Mother’s
and child’s mortality at the time of delivery.
For assistance during delivery, the mothers
who received assistance from doctor nurse/trained
midwife and family welfare visitor are considered
as mother having received assistance from a
“Health professional”. If the mother was assisted
by more than one type of provider, only the
most qualified person is recorded. The mothers
who received assistance from trained and untrained
traditional birth attendants (TBA) are considered
“TBA” category and in the “Others” category
the mothers’ had received assistance from a
relative, other, don’t know, or from no-one.
15.4 percent of mother’s delivery assistance
was a medically trained personal in the year
1990-1999. 44.4 percent of mothers took assistance
during delivery form a TBA and 40.2 percent
took assistance form other persons. In 2000-2004,
25.1 percent and 40.9 percent of mother’s delivery
assistance was medically trained personnel and
TBA respectively and the rest 34.0 percent took
assistance from others. Vitamin A capsules may
be regarded as a preventive management. Table
2 shows that 85.6 percent mothers took vitamin
A in 1990-1999 where the rate is low in 2000-2004
(67.1 percent).
Natal Care
Home deliveries are widely reported by
women in the study .Assistance during
delivery is an important element of delivery
care in reducing health risks for both mothers
and child. Proper health facilities and adequate
medical supervision along with safe, hygienic
conditions during delivery can reduce significantly
the risk of infections, and facilities management
of delivery related complications that may lead
to maternal or neonatal morbidity and/or mortality.
Developed countries are fully dependant on doctors
and nurses in the maternity hospitals for delivery
care. Bangladesh is a poor developing country
and maternity hospitals are quite inadequate.
Most of our pregnant mothers are mainly accustomed
to deliver births traditionally taking help
from their relatives or neighbors. The high
perinatal mortality and maternal mortality in
Bangladesh may be attributed to the low prevalence
of delivery care and assistance. Table 3 represents
that, about nineteen percent of mother’s place
of delivery is their own homes or other home
and 8.1 percent of mothers had gone to the government
or private hospitals for delivery cases in 1990-1999.
This situation has somewhat improved in 2000-2004
where 14 percent mothers choose government or
private hospital and 85.4 percent in their own
homes or others home for delivery. On the other
hand those that have assistance, among them
5.6 percent go to the doctor and 9.8 percent
go to a nurse/midwife and family welfare visitors,
in 1990-1999. In 2000-2004, 9.5 percent mothers
go to a doctor and 15.6 percent go to a nurse/midwife
and family welfare visitors. Besides these 40.2
percent mothers have assistance from others
in 1990-1999, whereas the rate is somewhat low
in 2000-2004 (34 percent).
| Table 3: Utilization of
Natal Care Services according two-time span
1990-1999 & 2000-2004 |
|
Background Characteristics |
Percentage |
| 1990-1999 |
2000-2004 |
|
Place of delivery
Respondent’s/ Others home
Govt'/ Private hospital
Public Place/ Others
|
91.6
8.1
0.3
|
85.4
14.0
0.6
|
|
Type of assistance
Medically trained persons
(Health professional)
Doctor
Nurse / Midwife & family welfare
visitors
TBA
Trained TBA
Untrained TBA
Other’s |
[
5.6
9.8
8.4
36.0
40.2
|
[
9.5
15.6
10.2
30.7
34.0
|
|
Told about pregnancy complications
Yes
No
|
24.8
75.2
|
31.0
69.0
|
|
Types
of complications Long labor
No
Yes
Excessive
bleeding
No
Yes
High
fever
No
Yes
Conculsion
No
Yes
|
85.1
14.9
92.1
7.9
96.5
3.5
96.7
3.3
|
82.7
17.3
88.8
11.2
95.2
4.8
96.7
3.3
|
It
is an important factor that mothers can inform
about their pregnancy complications. But generally
this is a rare case. Table 3 shows that about
one-quarter mothers can tell their pregnancy
complications in 1990-1999 and 31.0 percent
in 2000-2004. The rest of the mothers are unable
to inform of any complications about their pregnancy.
In response to a question whether mothers suffer
from any problem, about 21.9 percent of mothers
reported that they suffered from many types
of hazards in 1990-1999 and 26.1 percent in
2000-2004 (Table 3). The major delivery hazards
as experienced by the women in Bangladesh, include
prolonged labor (i.e. duration of true labor
or regular, rhythmic uterine contraction lasting
for more than 12 hours); excessive bleeding
which may be life threatening; high fever with
bad smelling vaginal discharge and convulsions
not cause by fever. 14.9 percent mothers suffered
from prolonged labor and 7.9 percent excessive
bleeding in 1990-1999 whereas the rate is slightly
higher (17.3 percent and 11.2 percent respectively)
in 2000-2004. 3.5 percent of mothers suffered
from high fever and 3.3 percent from convulsions
in 1990-1999 where the rate is 4.8 percent and
3.3 percent in 2000-2004 respectively.
Post Natal Care
A crucial component of safe motherhood
is postnatal care. Postnatal care is important
for mothers for treatment of complications arising
from delivery, especially for births that occur
at home. Postnatal checkups provide an opportunity
to assess and treat delivery complications and
to counsel mothers on how to care for themselves
and their newborns. In order to assess the extent
of postnatal care utilization, women whose most
recent live birth in the five years preceding
the survey was delivered outside a health facility
were asked whether they and/or the child received
a postnatal checkup from a health provider and
within how many days of delivery the checkup
was received. It is assumed that deliveries
in any health facility will receive a postnatal
checkup for the mother and the child within
the first two days of delivery, as a part of
routine institutional delivery care.
| Table 4: Utilization
of Post -Natal Care Services according two-time
span 1990-1999 & 2000-2004 |
|
Characteristics
|
Percentage |
| |
1990-1999 |
2000-2004 |
|
Received
postnatal care from a trained provider
(Mother)
Timing
Within 2 days of delivery
3-6 days after delivery
7-41 days after delivery
Within 42 days of delivery
Did not receive postnatal
checkup
|
12.0
0.2
1.4
14.0
78.0
|
14.5
0.6
2.6
17.8
82.2
|
|
Received postnatal care from
a trained provider (Children)
Timing
Within 2 days of delivery
3-6 days after delivery
7-41 days after delivery
Within 42 days of delivery
Did not receive postnatal
checkup
|
10.0
0.8
2.1
14.0
16.0
|
12.1
1.2
4.3
17.85
82.5
|
|
Vitamin-A
received by Children
Yes
No
|
11.8
88.2
|
14.9
85.1
|
|
Child
Vaccination
|
60.2
|
68.4
|
Table 4 shows that very few mothers in
Bangladesh receive postnatal care. Only 14 percent
of mothers received a postnatal checkup from
a trained health service provider within 42
days of delivery during the year 1990-1999 and
the corresponding figure for the year 2000-2004
is 17.8 percent. In Bangladesh, newborns are
as likely as their mothers to have received
postnatal care from a medically trained provider.
During the year 2000-2004 less than one in five
newborns is checked by a health professional
within six weeks of delivery. The timing of
postnatal care for newborns is important since
most neonatal deaths occur within two days of
delivery. The data indicates that during the
year 2000-2004 only 12 percent of babies received
a postnatal checkup by a trained health provider
within the first two days of delivery.
Vitamin A capsules may be regarded as
preventive management. It is also effective
in child morbidity especially it is the leading
factor to prevent childhood blindness. Table
4 shows that 11.8 percent children took vitamin
A in 1990-1999 where the rate is 14.9 percent
in 2000-2004 (67.1 percent).
Universal immunization of children under
one year of age against the six vaccine-preventable
diseases (tuberculosis; diphtheria, pertussis,
and tetanus [DPT]; poliomyelitis; and measles)
is one of the most cost-effective programs in
reducing infant and child morbidity and mortality.
The Expanded Program on Immunization (EPI) is
a priority program for the government of Bangladesh.
It follows the international guidelines recommended
by the World Health Organization (WHO). WHO
recommends that children receive all of these
vaccines before their first birthday. Overall,
68 percent of children age 12-23 months had
received all the recommended vaccinations before
their first birthday during the time span 2000-2004
and 60.2 percent during 1990-1999.
|
CONCLUSIONS
AND RECOMMENDATIONS
|
Bangladesh has achieved important health gains
over the last decade. However, equivalent progress
has not been realized in the area of maternal
health. The main focus of this study is to analyze
the patterns and determinants of maternal and
child health care services utilization in Bangladesh
with particular attention to the utilization
of maternal health care facilities for effective
antenatal care (ANC), tetanus toxoid injection,
delivery care, and delivery related complications.
The result shows that 47.3 percent women did
not take any ANC during pregnancy in the time
span 1990-1999 and 43.8 percent in 2000-2004.
It is a positive notation that mothers neglecting
ANC has decreased in 2000-2004 than 1990-1999.
Of those who receive some ANC, the majority
of them (27.2 percent) receive care from a qualified
doctor, 18.1 percent from nurse/trained midwives
and family welfare visitors and 7.2 percent
are from others, in 1990-1999. But these rates
are positively high and low in 2000-2004, whereas
31.6 percent go to a doctor, 19.5 percent go
to a nurse/trained midwife and family welfare
visitor and 4.8 percent haves ANC from others
in 2000-2004.
Out of them 45.3 percent of mothers have sufficient
antenatal care and only 7.4 percent of mothers
had insufficient antenatal care during 1990-1999.
On the other side during 2000-2004, sufficient
antenatal care has increased
(49.1 percent of mothers) and only 7.2 percent
of mothers had insufficient ANC during pregnancy.
It is a well-known fact that antenatal visits
should be taken in the specific months during
pregnancy.
Our study shows that most of the mothers (81.4
percent) had the first visit within six months,
12.6 percent of mothers had one at six to seven
months and only 6.0 percent of mother had care
at eight months or after in 1990-1999. But in
2000-2004, 78.4 percent and 11.7 percent of
mothers had a visit less than six months and
six to seven months respectively.
Only a few, 9.8 percent of mothers had it at
eight months or after eight months during pregnancy.
On the other hand 4.7 percent, 24.3 percent
and 13.7 percent of mothers has attended once,
2-3 times and more than 4 antenatal visits,
and 47.3 percent mother did not take any visits
respectively in 1990-1999. In 2000-2004 16.2
percent, 23.8 percent and 16.2 percent mother
made visits for once, two or three times and
more than four times respectively.
The proportion receiving tetanus (TT) injections
in the time span 2000-2004 has decreased than
in the time span 1990-1999. 17.3 percent mothers
did not take any dose, 22.6 percent of mother
had had only one dose and 60.1 percent of mothers
had two or more doses of tetanus toxoid (TT)
injections in 1990-1999. Besides these 26.0
percent of mother had one dose, 55.6 percent
had two or more doses and 18.4 percent of mother
had not had any dose in 2000-2004.
The utilization of health facilities for delivery
assistance shows a clear picture; 15.4 percent
of mother’s delivery assistance was by medically
trained personal in the time span 1990-1999.
44.4 percent of mothers had assistance during
delivery form TBAs and 40.2 percent had assistance
from other persons. In 2000-2004, 25.1 percent
and 40.9 percent of mother’s delivery assistance
was by medically trained personnel and TBAs
respectively and the rest, 34.0 percent form
others.
Regarding Natal care services,home deliveries
are widely reported by women in the study.This
study also reveals that about one-quarter of
mothers can relatetheir pregnancy complications
in 1990-1999 and 31.0 percent in 2000-2004.
The rest of mothers are unable to relate any
complications about their pregnancy. In response
to a question whether mothers suffer from any
problem, about 21.9 percent of mothers reported
that they suffered from many types of hazards
in 1990-1999 and 26.1 percent in 2000-2004.
14.9 percent mothers suffered from prolonged
labor and 7.9 percent from excessive bleeding
in 1990-1999 whereas the rate is slightly higher
(17.3 percent and 11.2 percent respectively)
in 2000-2004. 3.5 percent of mothers suffered
from high fever and 3.3 percent from convulsions
in 1990-1999 whereas the rate is 4.8 percent
and 3.3 percent in 2000-2004 respectively. With
respect to postnatal care services it was found
that very few mothers in Bangladesh receive
postnatal care.
Only 14 percent of mothers received a postnatal
checkup from a trained health service provider
within 42 days of delivery during the year 1990-1999
and the corresponding figure for the year 2000-2004
is 17.8 percent.
In Bangladesh, newborns are as likely as their
mothers to have received postnatal care from
a medically trained provider. During the years
2000-2004 less than one in five newborns is
checked by a health professional within six
weeks of delivery. The timing of postnatal care
for newborns is important since most neonatal
deaths occur within two days of delivery.
The data indicates that during the year 2000-2004
only 12 percent of babies received a postnatal
checkup by a trained health provider within
the first two days of delivery. It is also found
that 11.8 percent if children took vitamin A
in 1990-1999 whereas the rate is 14.9 percent
in 2000-2004 (67.1 percent). The study also
identified that during the time span 2000-2004
and 1990-1999 68.4 and 60.2 percent of children
age 12-23 months had received all the recommended
vaccinations before their first birthday.
Based on the discussion some recommendations
have been suggested that would help the government
to take initiatives to promote maternal and
child health care facilities.
- The results of this study indicate
that there is a strong need to focus strategic
measures upon the increase of health facilities,
such as the THC, health clinic and FWC. Emphasis
should be given to the IEC activities of the
national health programme that communities,
particularly the poor and uneducated women
become aware of the need for regular antenatal
care check up and safe deliveries by competent
health personnel. Trained TBAs should be linked
with the health service facility-delivery
system at different levels to ensure their
utilization.
- There is a further need to investigate
with regard to the efforts of Programmatic
(e.g., accessibility and cost of antenatal
services) on the antenatal care seeking behavior
of Bangladeshi women.
- As most people go to TBAs and village
doctors they should be given proper training
and integrated into the main stream of government
health intervention programmes, which should
upgrade the poor maternal and child health
care status existing in Bangladesh to a greater
extent.
- Policies to expand educational opportunities,
particularly for girls, would increase the
access to information and health services
and improve their ability to make good use
of it in order to lead healthier lives.
Ahmed, N. U., M.F. Zeitlin, A.S. Beiser,
C.M. Super and S.N. Gersoff. 1993. A longitudinal
study of the impact of behavioral change intervention
on cleanliness, diarrhoeal morbidity and growth
of children in rural Bangladesh. Social
Science and Medicine 37(2): 159-171
Ahmed, S. F. Sobhan and A. Islam.
1998. Neonatal morbidity
and care-seeking behavior in rural areas in
Bangladesh. Operational Research Project-
Health and Population Extension Division.
Working Paper No. 148. Dhaka: International
center for Diarrhoeal Diseases Research, Bangladesh
Caldwell, J. C. 1990.
Cultural and Social factors influencing mortality
levels in developing countries. Annuals
of the American Academy of Political and social
Science 510: 44-59.
Cox, D.R. 1970.The Analysis
of Binary Data. London: Methuen.
Cox, D.R. 1984. Analysis
of Survival Data. London: Chapman and Hall
Mitra, S.N., M. Nawab Ali, S. Islam,
A.R. Cross, and T. Saha. 1994.Bangladesh
Demographic andHealth Survey 1993-94. Calverton,
Maryland: National Institute for Population
Research and Training (NIPORT), Mitra
and Associates, and Macro International Inc.
Moller, B., O. Lushino, O. Meiric,
M. Gebre-Medhin, G. Lindmark. 1989.
A study of antenatal care at village level
in rural Tanjania. International Journal
of Gynaecol and Obsterics 30(2): 123-131.
Park K. 1997. Preventive
and Social Medicine. Fifteenth edition,
Jabalpur, 482001 India.
United Nations Chidren’s Fund (UNICEF).
1996. Revised 1990 estimates
of maternal mortality: A new approach by
UNICEF.
UNFPA. (October 1996).
Strengthening MCH/FP Services at MCWCs in
Bangladesh. (Dhaka University: UNFPA).
World Bank. 1991.World
Development Report. Washington D.C:Oxford
University Press.
|