Hypertensive
patients attending military family medicine clinics
in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia
.........................................................................................................................
Abdul-Aziz F. Alkabbaa
Consultant Family
Medicine,
Associate Dean for Academic Affairs,
Faculty of Medicine,
King Saud Bin Abdul-Aziz University for Health
Sciences,
King Fahad Medical City, Riyadh,
Saudi Arabia
|
ABSTRACT
Objective: To characterize adult patients
with hypertension attending Armed Forces
family medicine clinics in Tabuk, Saudi
Arabia.
Methods: Ten percent of all patients
attending Armed Forces family medicine
clinics in 2003 were selected by stratified
systematic random sampling. Data about
age, sex, diagnosis, referrals, follow
up, health education, co-morbidities were
collected from patients' (age >18
yrs) medical records using a pilot-tested
data collection form and analyzed using
SPSS 10 (P <.05). Hypertension was
defined according to WHO criteria.
Results: The prevalence of hypertension
was 7.3% (n =7644; mean age, 33.5 13.1
years). Patients with hypertension were
significantly older (53.6 versus 33.5
years, respectively) and significantly
more likely to have diabetes mellitus
(44.3% versus 7.1%, respectively) than
patients without hypertension. Patients
with hypertension were followed up (78.8%
versus 3.2%, respectively) and offered
a health education session (75% versus
14.4%, respectively) significantly more
often than were patients without hypertension.
Conclusion:
Hypertension is common among patients
attending family clinics in Tabuk; the
prevalence increases with age. Patients
with hypertension receive more health
education and follow up than do patients
without hypertension. Evaluating the content
and outcomes of the education and follow-up
visits could help to develop more effective
interventions.
|
Hypertension is a chronic
condition that causes serious morbidity and
mortality in many countries, including Saudi
Arabia. The associated socioeconomic burden
on the individual, family, and community is
tremendous. Worldwide surveys show that the
prevalence of hypertension varies widely in
different countries, ranging from 3.4% in men
in rural India to 72.5% in women in Poland(1).
The overall worldwide prevalence among the adult
population is reported to be 26.4% (26.6% and
26.1% for men and women, respectively). Should
the current trend continue, the prevalence is
projected reach 29.2% (29.0% and 29.5% for men
and women, respectively) by the year 2025, totaling
about 1.6 billion cases. Two-thirds of cases
will occur in developing countries(2).
Rapid socioeconomic development in Saudi Arabia,
with extensive expansion of educational and
health facilities programs (including environmental
health), has led to a reduction in the incidence
of communicable diseases. As a result, awareness
of the public health importance of chronic non-communicable
diseases, such as hypertension, has increased.
Hypertension is responsible for a large proportion
of outpatient consultations. Obtaining reliable
information about the prevalence of hypertension
and associated factors is crucial for developing
a comprehensive strategy for preventing and
controlling hypertension.
North West Armed Forces Hospital Program (NWAFH)
in Tabuk was established by the Ministry of
Defense and Aviation, and it is one of the most
modern and well-equipped military hospitals
in the kingdom of Saudi Arabia. Providing quality
health care services as required for the optimal
care and treatment for patients is within the
scope of the Saudi Arabian Armed Forces Medical
Services Directorate responsibilities. General
practitioner services for the military community
and hospital employees are provided on an outpatient
basis by the Family Medicine Clinics.
The objectives of this study, the first of
its nature and magnitude, were to determine
the proportion and characteristics of adult
patients (18 years of age and older) with hypertension
who attended NWAFH Family Medicine Clinics in
Tabuk City. The results of the study will help
to develop appropriate health policies and programs
for preventing, detecting, and controlling hypertension
in the community.
The current study was a cross-sectional study,
conducted from January 1, 2003 through to December
31, 2003. The study population was all patients
18 years of age and older who attended NWAFH
Family Medicine Clinics in Tabuk, Saudi Arabia
during the study period. Tabuk City is the Capital
of the North West region of Saudi Arabia, and
has a population of approximately 500,000.
Stratified systematic random sampling was used
to select 10% (14,694) of the Family Medicine
Clinic encounters during the study period from
the tally sheets used for daily encounter registration.
To ensure selection of a random representative
sample, the strata included all working days
of the week for the entire study period.
Physicians collected the following data from
patients' medical records using a pilot-tested
data collection form: age; sex; provisional
and final diagnosis; referral to specialty clinics
in the hospital and feedback; follow up appointments;
health education documentation; chronic co-morbidities;
smoking status, and the frequency of visits
per year.
The study was approved by a research and ethics
committee at North West Armed Forces Hospital
in Tabuk; permissions were obtained from the
appropriate related authorities.
Collected data was checked for completeness
before being fed into a personal computer. A
double entry method was used to decrease data
entry errors. The International Classification
of Health Care Problems in Primary Care (ICHPPC-2)
was used for disease and health problem classification.
Statistical analysis was performed using Statistical
Package for Social Sciences (SPSS-10) with the
level of statistical significance set at P <
.05.
Hypertension was defined according to WHO criteria:
systolic blood pressure >140 mmHg or diastolic
pressure > 90 mmHg or both, or currently
receiving pharmacologic or non-pharmacologic
treatment for hypertension.
Of the patient encounters selected (n = 14,694),
556 (3.8%) were excluded due to the incomplete
information in some study variables. These patients
did not differ significantly from the included
patients in age or sex. All of the remaining
14,138 encounters were analyzed. This communication
dealt only with subjects who are 18 years or
above (n = 7644). The mean age of the adult
patients (18 years of age and older) who attended
the clinics during the study period was 33.48
years (SD, 13.10; range, 18-97 years).
| Age
in years |
Female,
n (%)
|
Male,
n (%)
|
Total,
N (%)
|
| 18-24 |
1213
(30.7)
|
993
(26.9)
|
2206
(28.9)
|
| 25-44 |
2122
(53.7)
|
1992
(54.0)
|
4114
(53.8)
|
| 45-64 |
485
(12.3)
|
559
(15.2)
|
1044
(13.7)
|
| 65 and
older |
135
(3.4)
|
145
(3.9)
|
280
(3.7)
|
| Total |
3955
(51.7)
|
3689
(48.3)
|
7644
(100)
|
| Mean
(SD) |
32.83
(12.99)
|
34.18
(13.20)
|
33.48
(13.10)
|
P value < .0001
Table 1: Age and sex distributions of the study
sample
| Age
in years |
Female,
n (%)
|
Male,
n (%)
|
Total,
N (%)
|
| 18-24 |
2.1
( 6)
|
1.1
(3)
|
1.6
(9)
|
| 25-44 |
28.5
(75)
|
23.7
(63)
|
24.8
(138)
|
| 45-64 |
49.5
(144)
|
54.5
(145)
|
51.9
(289)
|
| 65
and older |
22.7
(66)
|
20.7
(55)
|
27.1
(121)
|
| Total |
52.2
(291)
|
47.8
(266)
|
100
(557)
|
| Prevalence
of hypertension |
7.4
%
|
7.2%
|
7.3%
|
| Mean
(SD) |
54.03
(14.08)
|
53.06
(13.41)
|
53.57
(13.76)
|
Table 2: Age and sex distributions of patients
with hypertension
Tables 1 and 2 show the age and sex distribution
of all subjects and subjects with hypertension,
respectively. Of the 7,644 adult patients, 557
had hypertension, giving an overall prevalence
of 7.3%. The proportion of women in both groups
slightly exceeded that of men (approximately
52%). For both sexes in both groups, more than
80% were younger than 45 years of age and less
than 4% were older than 65 years of age. The
mean age of all subjects was 33.48 years (SD,
13.10), with women being significantly younger
than men (32.8 years versus 34.2 years). Patients
with hypertension were significantly older than
were patients without hypertension (53.6 versus
33.5 years, respectively). Women were more likely
to have hypertension than were men, and women
with hypertension were older than men with hypertension;
however, these differences were not significant.
| Variable |
Hypertension
|
X
2***
|
DF**
|
P
*
|
| Age
(years) |
% No (n = 7087) |
% Yes (n = 557) |
|
|
|
|
| 18-24 |
|
1426.5
|
3
|
.001
|
| 25-44 |
|
|
|
|
| 45-64 |
|
|
|
|
| 65 and
older |
|
|
|
|
| Sex |
|
|
|
|
| Female |
|
0.805
|
1
|
.42
|
| Male |
|
|
|
|
| Health
Education |
|
|
|
|
| No |
|
1269.5
|
1
|
.001
|
| Yes |
|
|
|
|
| Diabetes
Mellitus |
|
|
|
|
| No |
|
806
|
1
|
.001
|
| Yes |
|
|
|
|
| Follow
up |
|
|
|
|
| No |
|
54.5
|
1
|
.001
|
| Yes |
|
|
|
|
*P, P-value; **DF, Degrees of freedom; ***
2, P-value, Chi Square
Table 3: Characteristic of the study population
Table 3 compares the characteristic of patients
with and without hypertension. Patients with
hypertension received significantly more health
education and follow up visits than did patients
without hypertension; patients with hypertension
were also significantly older. Patients with
hypertension were more likely to have diabetes
mellitus than were patients without hypertension.
Women were affected more than males, but this
difference was not significant. Among patients
with hypertension, there were no significant
sex-related differences for health education,
co-morbid diabetes, or follow up visits (Table
4).
| Variables |
Male |
Female |
x2*** |
DF** |
P* |
| Age
(years) |
% No
(n) |
% Yes
(n) |
|
|
|
| 18-24 |
2.1
(6) |
1.1
(3) |
1.929 |
3 |
.587 |
| 25-44 |
25.8
(75) |
23.7
(63) |
|
|
|
| 45-64 |
49.5
(144) |
54.5
(145) |
|
|
|
| 65 and
older |
22.7
(66) |
20.7
(55) |
|
|
|
| Health
Education |
|
|
|
|
|
| Yes |
24.4
(71) |
24.1
(64) |
0.926 |
1 |
.503 |
| No |
75.6
(220) |
75.9
(202) |
|
|
|
| Diabetes
Mellitus |
|
|
|
|
|
| Yes |
54.0
(157) |
57.5
(153) |
0.397 |
1 |
.220 |
| No |
45.0
(134) |
42.5
(113) |
|
|
|
| Follow
up |
|
|
|
|
|
| Yes |
21.7
(63) |
20.8
(53) |
0.82 |
1 |
|
| No |
78.3
(227) |
79.1
(210) |
|
|
|
| Total |
291 |
266 |
|
|
|
*P, P-value; **DF, Degrees of freedom; ***
2, P-value, Chi Square
Table 4: Characteristics of patients with hypertension
Hypertension is one of the most common non-communicable
diseases worldwide, including in Saudi Arabia.
Our data showed that more women than men attended
the clinics during the study period, which follows
the pattern typical for primary care clinics
in Saudi Arabia(3).
The overall prevalence of hypertension in this
study was about 7.3 %. In similar settings for
the Ministry of Defense and Aviation and the
Ministry of Health, the prevalence of hypertension
among attending adult patients ranged from 3.1%
to 10% and 2.4% to 30%, respectively(4-6). Recent
community surveys showed that the overall prevalence
among adults in different regions of the country
was 26.1%(7). In other countries in the region,
hypertension is estimated to affect 20-32.1
% of adult population(8,9,10,11). Various population-based
studies conducted in other developing countries
have shown that the prevalence of hypertension
ranges from 9% to 30% among adults(12,13). In
highly developed countries, the reported prevalence
of hypertension among adults ranges from 38%
to 55% in Europe and is 28% in North America(14).
Making comparisons among these studies is problematic
because of the difference in the definitions
and methodologies used and the characteristics
of the populations studied. Nonetheless, the
message is clear: hypertension among adults
is an important problem, and meaningful interventions
are needed.
This study showed the significant relationship
between hypertension and advancing age in both
sexes. Cross-sectional surveys and prospective
cohort studies have consistently demonstrated
a positive relationship between age and blood
pressure in the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia and
in most populations regardless of geographical,
cultural, and socioeconomic characteristics
(3-7,15,16).
The association between sex and hypertension
is less clear. Some studies have reported that
hypertension was more prevalent in men, while
others have reported the opposite. Many studies
have reported that hypertension is more prevalent
among men at younger ages and more prevalent
among women at older ages. The association between
hypertension and sex is complex and can be confounded
by other factors such as socioeconomic status
and education. Overall, no apparent sex predilection
has been demonstrated (1-2).
Our data showed that patients with hypertension
received more health education sessions during
their clinic visits than did patients without
hypertension. This finding was not unexpected:
hypertension is associated with many risk factors
and is itself a risk factor for many serious
diseases and complications. In most cases, management
of hypertension entails life-long pharmacologic
and non-pharmacologic interventions. In order
to encourage adherence to these life-long regimens,
continuing education that promotes positive
attitudes and behaviors is needed (17).
Patients with hypertension had more scheduled
visits than did patients without hypertension.
This finding was also expected for the same
reasons discussed above. While follow up visits
are necessary, the economic considerations must
be revisited. Consultations for hypertension
were shown to account for 67% of the direct
costs of managing patients with hypertension
in Eastern Saudi Arabia (18). It should be noted
that patients with hypertension were offered
the same health education and follow up services
regardless of age, sex, or co-morbidity; this
is a welcome finding.
The prevalence of diabetes mellitus in patients
with hypertension was nearly 40% in our sample,
in accordance with previously reported figures
(19,20). The prevalence of multi-morbidity is
high and increases significantly with age in
both men and women. Patients with multi-morbidity
who are seen in family practice represent the
rule rather than the exception, and new health
care models must be developed to meet the needs
of these patients(21).
Hypertension is a common problem in patients
attending NWAFH family medicine clinics in Tabuk
City, Saudi Arabia. The prevalence of hypertension
increases with age and hypertension is more
common among patients with diabetes. Patients
with hypertension receive more health education
messages and follow up visits than do patients
without hypertension, as is appropriate. The
content and outcomes of these messages and follow
up visits should be evaluated further in order
to develop interventions that are more effective.
Our data indicates that hypertension affects
a large proportion of adults in Tabuk and suggests
that many patients known to have hypertension
are not visiting the family clinics and that
many individuals may have undiagnosed hypertension.
Future intervention strategies should target
primordial, primary, and secondary prevention.
Guidelines for pharmacologic and non-pharmacologic
management need to be developed and standardized.
It is anticipated that implementation of such
guidelines would lead to improved patient outcomes
at a lower cost.
1- Kearney P, Whelton M, Reynolds K, Whelton
P, He J. Worldwide prevalence of hypertension:
a systematic review. J Hypertens 2004; 22(1):
11-19
2- Kearney P, Whelton M, Reynolds K, Whelton
P, He J. Global burden of hypertension : analysis
of worldwide data. Lancet,2005;365(9455):
317 - 223.
3- Statistics Year Book 2002-2003. Ministry
of Health, Riyadh Saudi Arabia
4- Nazim Uddin K. Prevalence of hypertension
in Saudi Arabia . The Practitioner 1994;5
(11):905 -806.
5- Mahfouz Z, al-Erian R. Hypertension in
Assir region , south western Saudi Arabia:
an epidemiologic study. Southeast Asian J
Trop Med and Public Health , 1993; 24(2) :
284 - 286.
6- Kalantan K, Mahmoud A, Al-Taweel A, Abdulghani
H. Hypertension among attendants of primary
health care centers in Al-Qassim region, Saudi
Arabia. Saudi M J 2002; 22(1): 960 -963.
7- Alnozha M, Abdullah M, Arafa M, Khalid
M, Al Mazrou Y, Al-Matoog M, Almarzougki K,
Al-Khadra A, Nouh M, Al-Harthi S, Al-Shahid
M, Al-Moberreek A. Hypertension in Saudi Arabia.
Saudi M J 2007; 28(1): 77 -84.
8- Hasab A, Jaffer A, Hallaj Z,. Blood pressure
patterns among the Omani population. East
Mediterranean Health Journal , 1999; 5(1):
46 - 54.
9- Saaaf-Zadegan N, Boshtam M, Mostafavi S,
Rafiei M. Prevalence of hypertension and associated
risk factors in Islamic Republic of Iran.
Health Journal, 1999; 5(5): 992 - 1001.
10- Bener A, Al-Suwaidi J, Al-Jaber K, Al-Marri
S, Dagash M, Elbagi I. The prevalence of hypertension
and its associated risk factors in a newly
developed country. Saudi M J 2004;25(7) :
918 - 922.
11- Altun B, Arici M, Nergizoglu G, Derici
U, Karatan O, Turgan C, Sindel S, Erbay B,
Hasanoglu E, Cagler S. Prevalence, awareness
, treatment and control of hypertension in
Turkey( the patent T study) in 2003. J Hypertens
200; 23(10): 1817 - 1823.
12- Edwards R, Unwin N, Mugusi F, Whiting
D, Rashid S, Kissima J, Aspray T, Aberti K.
Hypertension prevalence and care in an urban
and rural area of Tanzania . J hypertens 2000,
18)2): 45 - 152
13- Allah A, Inamo A, Larabi L, de Gademaris
R. Arterial hypertension in the French Caribbean
regions : gender related differences. Arch
Mal Cour Vaiss, 2005; 98(7-8): 845 -849.
14- Wall-Mair K, Cooper R, Banegas J, Giamapaoli
S, Hens H, Loffres M, Kastarien M, Poulter
N, Primatseta P, Artalejo F, Stagnayr B, Thawm
F. Hypertension prevalence and blood pressure
levels in 6 Euopean countries, Canada and
the United States. JAMA, 2003;289(18): 2363
-2369
15- Erem C, Hacihasangoglu A, Kocak M, Deger
O, Tobas M. Prevalence of prehypertension
and hypertension and associated risk factors
among Turkish adults: Trabzon Hypertension
Study. J Public Health,2008:1-2
16- Rampal L, Rampal S, Azhaar S, Rahman A.
Prevalence, awareness, treatment and control
of hypertension in Malaysia: a national study
of 16440 subjects. Public Health, 2008 122(1):
11-18.
17- Bell R, Kravitz R. Physician counseling
for hypertension: what do doctors really do?
Patient educ Couns, 2008: 72(1): 115 -121.
18- Al-Shahri M , A.. Mandil , Elzubier A,.
Hanif M. Epidemiological aspects and cost
of managing hypertension in Saudi Arabian
primary health care centre. Eastern Mediterranean
Health Journal, 1998;4(3): 493 -501
19. Al-Shehri A. Blood pressure control among
type 2 diabetics. Saudi M J , 2008; 29(5):
718 - 722.
20- L-Tuwaijri A, Al-Rukban A. Hypertension
control and co-morbidities in primary health
care centers in Riyadh. Ann Saudi Med, 2006;
26(4) ; 266 -271.
21- Fortin, M., Bravo, G., Hudon, C., Lapointe,
L.. Prevalence of Multi-morbidity Among Adults
Seen in Family Practice Ann Fam Med. 2005
May; 3(3): 223-228.
|